Clearing the PR Pollution that Clouds Climate Science

Desmog Video

You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video.


 



Climate Change Cancelled! (Whew!)

Good News! Climate change is all a big mistake! This remarkable finding was revealed by Michael Asher in Daily Tech – a publication more focused on iPhones than atmospheric science.

Asher’s piece Sea Ice Ends Year at Same Level as 1979 confidently states that “Thanks to a rapid rebound in recent months, global sea ice levels now equal those seen 29 years ago…”

Strange. That’s not what scientists are saying. Just last month NASA released a chilling report showing that between 1.5 trillion and 2 trillion tons of ice in Greenland, Antarctica and Alaska have melted at an accelerating rate since 2003 – enough to fill Chesapeake Bay 21 times.

The satellite survey of global ice loss showed that in the past five years, Greenland has lost between 150 gigatons and 160 gigatons each year. One gigaton equals one billion tons or enough to raise global sea levels about .5 mm per year

"It's not getting better; it's continuing to show strong signs of warming and amplification," said NASA ice scientist Jay Zwally. "There's no reversal taking place."

Scientists studying sea ice announced that parts of the Arctic north of Alaska were 9 to 10 degrees warmer this past fall, a strong early indication of what researchers call the Arctic amplification effect.

Positive feedback loops and accelerating climate change occur when reflective sea ice melts and allows sunlight to be instead absorbed by open water. Melting permafrost can also release massive amounts of CO2 and dangerous methane. Playing with the thermostat of the planet is deadly serious and extremely worrying to researchers.

"The pace of change is starting to outstrip our ability to keep up with it, in terms of our understanding of it," said Mark Serreze, senior scientist at the National Snow and Ice Data Center in Boulder, Colo., a co-author of the Arctic amplification study.

So what about the bold dismissal of climate change by Michael Asher in the electronic gadget blog? Nothing new there. He seems like just another off-the-shelf climate denier with no apparent scientific credentials.

Asher has made a monotonous habit of slagging climate science. Have a look at the titles of some of his past posts:

  • Climate Report Downgrades Ice Loss; Media Reports Opposite
  • Princeton Physicist Calls Global Warming Science "Mistaken"
  • Defying Predictions, Sea Level Rise Begins to Slow
  • Glaciers in Norway Growing Again
  • Electric Car Sales in Freefall; Industry Risks Collapse
  • How to Reduce Pollution by Drilling for Oil
  • Study Finds Health Problems from Wind Farms
  • Oxygen Depletion: The Next Great Environmental Scare

You get the idea.

There is certainly nothing new about hacks like Asher holding forth with irresponsible, baseless and boring claims of how the entire scientific community has got it wrong on climate science.

I look forward to the day when they will be treated with the same deference as people who wear tin foil hats so space aliens won’t read their brain waves.

What's next?

Climate Change...

I think this climate change is because of global warming and even scientist cannot prevent this from happening..I hope people will join hand in hand for the good of our environment and mother earth.

resveratrol side effects

Hi

Yes! Your Right ...If we can get a alternate fuel to gasoline then we can solve it by 90%

Sravan
Thanks

Sravan
http://www.PlayGhost.com

doubtable

It is really a good news but i highly doubt it is not true.

registry cleaners

Good

Thanks for the post
This is really true

i think this is a good

i think this is a good information thank you for post the information^^

Buzz News

some say....

some say that the earth is actually getting colder.

Some really 'clever' scientists are suggesting its getting colder.

 

I think it's getting warmer, but then colder.

 

Gas Gift Cards

Climate Change is a Reality

Those who refuse to believe that climate change is a reality are living in cloud cuckoo land.  Global warming is happening, and any other 'opinions' or 'facts' which state otherwise are clearly driven by other agendas or on bad science.

Free Forex Signals | Forex Signals

 

  Well...i think that it is a

 

Well...i think that it is a big good news for everyone. I like this blog and its contents are also very good and wrothtful.

http://resveratrol-ultra.wetpaint.com

great advice

Some really well researched factual advice in this post that well can all take on board.

Bluestone

Re: Climate Change Cancelled! (Whew!)

Nice post this is really interesting, i rate this post

Vigrx Vimax 

Global Warming

Problem of global warming is being known from so many years now is he time for solution man!

Wedding Dresses 2009

Wedding flowers

Wow I am sorry for quick

Wow I am sorry for quick replies but what is goin on around us. Can you not see. Please somebody do somethin about this.

hair removal

laser hair removal

permanent hair removal

hair electrolysis

Interesting discussion. What

Interesting discussion. What does this guy mean anayways. occurrence is so important that it warrants a big blaring headline, then it's probably not very frequent. And indeed, it's not very frequent. I really dont underdtand what is that?

laptop charger


climate change

climate change occur when reflective sea ice melts and allows sunlight to be instead absorbed by open water.

Colon Cleanse

Acne Treatment

Climate Change

Funny how they first thought that there was no such thing as global warming and blamed everything on it being just a over hyped hox at the time. 

Ways to Make Money Online Fast Ways to Make Money Online

Global warming and climate

Global warming and climate calamity have become the liberal justification for genocide.

Resveratrol

Colon Cleanse

Well that's a little extreme,

Well that's a little extreme, but I do sometimes question the political motivation behind the global warming movement. I'm not sure if we'll ever know if human activity causes changes in the global climate or if it's just another one of earth's cycles.

 

Freight Factoring Company

If the climate change was

If the climate change was cancelled then why the global warming is increasing? The trouth is a lot of glaciers are melting.

Kidney Infection Symptoms

Global Warming

Global warming is happening how can you explain the dramitic rise in tempature. Where are our polar caps going???

Daniel, bad credit loans

I guess I read that blog, and

I guess I read that blog, and it odd to me because it is opposite to what NASA and other scientist is saying. How on earth he can say those thing when we can see in our own naked eyes how's the iceberg melting in a rapid way.  


Global warming is a true

Global warming is a worldwide problem. Scientists who are denying this fact are political agents of those countries that are guilty of creating this problem.

Hair loss products bbq grills

It's easy really!

One of the most inspiring things that I've seen recently about the whole global warming issue was on a poster in Florida. I forget the details, but it really helped change my perspective on what we're doing to the Earth. Basically it pointed out that the Earth we currently occupy is borrowed from our children rather than inherited from our parents. The expectation being when we borrow something we should return it in the condition we received it!

When you look at it like this, it really makes you think about what impact we're having, and how our children will have to bear the consequences. How selfish of us.

As Gandhi said let's "become the change we want to see in the world".

Nikon D5000 Camera

Um.....that's huge

Just to give people an idea of how massive the Chesapeake Bay is, the watershed is 5 times bigger than the state of Maryland and 30 times bigger than Delaware...

-----

Chris

Stop Elder Abuse | Report Elder Abuse

Good if it was true!

We are looking to listen this news in future. The NASA is right. I don't know why some people don't believe that climate is changing?

Lets stop talking and do something that we can do to save the climate.

 

 

Earn Money Online

 

What Can Be Done?

My question is what can be done to avoid global warming,any one has some idea?

Alaska Cruises

Good News

Scary

The statistics that you have provided are just downright frightening. One has to wonder if it may just be too late to reverse the eventual outcome.

~Jane - Trivia Questions

Should be controlled

Global warming is something that might be controlled ASAP othwerwise our kids will have avery dark future.

Article Directory

Yes true i agree with you but

Yes true i agree with you but the question is what can be done.

Alaska Cruises

I've bookmarked this

I've bookmarked this article!

 

Earn Money Taking Online Surveys

Vigrx

I have bookmarked this interesting article. Nice Read!

Vigrx

Why so many?

Why do so many people not beleive in Global Warming, it's obviously happening, we can't keep destroying the natural earth and expect it to be ok can we.

Dog Training

I tire of the self-righteous

I tire of the self-righteous approach of the global warming camp. I'm reminded of a comment by Einstein: "Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of truth and knowledge is shipwrecked by the laughter of the gods." Science is never "closed." Debate should be encouraged. Ridicule should cease. If a claim is shown to be false, then it should be abandoned. Let's move forward from "us and them."

 

Richie

Make Money Online

So in other words you don't

So in other words you don't believe in global warming?

How do you consider the trend of average world temperatures then? It's going up for the last decade...

Vicky from Ed Hardy Clothing store

Thats a great one. Enjoyed


Thats a great one. Enjoyed reading it thanks.

Forex Investment

Automated Forex

 

Global warming is very dangerous

Government should take immediate action to avoid global warming acai berry  acai berry oprah

It's true

climate change is true. the effects are already showing in asian countries. I'm from malaysia anyway.

 

http://dog-dogs-dog.blogspot.com

Interesting

I have been tracking the extent of sea ice, too, at NSIDC.  First, the season isn't over, and second, the graph has been giving the 2006-07 minimum record a run for its money.  http://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index/images/daily_images/N_timeseries.png

Global warming

Actually, there are a large number of scientists who do not believe in global warming.  They've been saying that the earth is actually getting colder. This winter might be an indication of that, lol

 

Angela from Aberdeen

Backlinks

Belief Has Religious Connotations

You are wrong when it comes to climate scientists, they do not believe in global warming like someone believes in some superstition like a lucky white rabbit's foot.

Scientists are objective and are convinced by weighing-up the scientific evidence. Since the objective evidence regarding climate change is unequivocal (one-sided) showing that the earth is warming it takes a truly remarkable bindness to the truth to ignore the huge imbalance of evidence that demonstrates a warming world to conclude that the earth is cooling.

As for large number, either you are referring to the widely debumnked Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine's Petition Project and its associated junk science article 'environmental Effects of Carbon Dioxide' which has been widely debunked.

Alternatively you may be referring to one of the lists of scientists invented by various deniers and think-tanks that misleadingly include numerous scientists whose work in no way disputes anthropogenic climate change.

These lists are unreliable, or are downright dishonest and to quote these as if they somehow counter the conclusions of the IPCC, or Naomi Oreskes' research is dishonest in the extreme.

No,

there are a few unscroupulous people who create lists of "scientists" who do not believe in global warming.

It has been shown repeatedly that a good many of those "scientists" have no relevant expertise in fields qualifying them to judge the scientific evidence on global warming and climate change, that others are not in fact "scientists" at all, that some are in fact dead or non-existent, and even that some are qualified scientists who actually subscribe to the consensus theory of anthropogenic global warming and climate change but that their words have been deliberately taken out of context and misconstrued to make it sound like they do not.

What's left is a very short list indeed, consisting of the same few names of scientists that are already well known for their skepticism of the theory of anthropogenic global warming and climate change. Some of their points are valid but unproven or overblown, others have long since been shown to be totally and completely bogus.

Any of them who assert that the earth is actually getting colder are either completely incompetent or deliberately lying.

See here: http://tamino.wordpress.com/2008/12/31/stupid-is-as-stupid-does/
and here: http://tamino.wordpress.com/2009/01/08/cold-hard-facts/
and here: http://moregrumbinescience.blogspot.com/2009/01/results-on-deciding-trends.html

Unscrupulous, incompetent and lying

Jim,

Forgive me, but this is a link to the Senate Committee of (gasp!!) Sen. Inhofe. It's okay, really ... I viewed the page and did not turn into a pillar of salt. I'm supposing that you believe he personally and single-handedly coerced all the individuals in this report into making the bogus claims that they do, such is his power:

http://epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Files.View&FileStore_id=83947f5d-d84a-4a84-ad5d-6e2d71db52d9

The list seems to be growing, but feel free to dismiss the entire assemblage with the wave of your magical AGW hand. After all, they are most likely unscrupulous, incompetent or dang-it-all-anyway ... just plain liers.

No there isn't

>"there are a large number of scientists who do not believe in global warming"

No there isn't: http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/306/5702/1686

 

Also, you're confusing climate (long-term trends) with weather (it feels a bit nippy in my town today). Actually, it sounds like you might even be confusing seasons with climate change?

 

Hmm...Not sure. There are

Hmm...Not sure.

There are scientists who don't agree with the mainstream findings and they too don't believe that what we are going through is global warming- they call it cycles.

I know that in Australia, last summer was the hottest since 100 years and the records showed that 100 years the weather conditions that is temperature was very very similar, which is why they call it cycles.

Look I still think that CO2 is a big problem and that we need active solutions that minimise our footprint, but I don't know if it is global warming or not. hmm...

 Graphic Design Melbourne | Web Design Melbourne

all scientists believe

I assume all scientists believe in "global warming" It's the degree of man's involvement in the whole thing that causes confusion. If a scientist is less convinced of the weight of mankind on the climate, he is labeled a "global warming denier" even though he is fully convinced of global warming. It's a shame and a misuse of words.

Just curious

Did any of you folks at Desmogblog either write Michael Asher or respond to the column  in his comments section (presuming they have one there) and ask him to explain how he could come up with his conclusions?

It's all well and good to rebut him, but only if he's made aware that he's getting rebutted.

 

The "no such thing as AGW"

The "no such thing as AGW" voices definetely seem to be increasing in volume and number. You can get your "no agw" fix in a lot of different flavors too - ranting, reasoning, technical, political - whatever you like - and I'd say it's not going to blow over any time soon.

How dare they!

How dare they resort to "reasoning" and "technical" arguments to rebut global warming! What is this world coming to when these voices are allowed to be heard? Silence them all and off with their heads!

How dare they refute Time magazine's off the cuff comment that global warming was to blame for the Hudson river plane crash.

How dare they shed light on the misleading comment that part of the Greenland ice sheet "an area the size of Manhatten Island" melted (gasp!), without indicating that this represents a miniscule .03% of the entire ice sheet.

How dare they give factual information on global temperatures since 2001 that show a cooling trend that flies in the face of every model prediction relied upon by the IPCC that show continued warming over this period, not one of which predicted this cooling.

How dare they refute the implication that tropical storms will increase dramatically due to warming, even after NOAA has stated that no such trend will emerge and in fact, warming would likely decrease the incidence of tropical storms due to to a more equitable temperature balance between the equator and the poles. Shame on Al Gore for putting a hurricane on the cover of his movie and thus cementing it in the minds of the unsuspecting an image that is completely contrary to the fact that their occurance has absolutely NOTHING to do with warming. A red herring ploy at its finest.

I tire of the self-righteous approach of the global warming camp. I'm reminded of a comment by Einstein: "Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of truth and knowledge is shipwrecked by the laughter of the gods." Science is never "closed." Debate should be encouraged. Ridicule should cease. If a claim is shown to be false, then it should be abandoned. Let's move forward from "us and them."

And of course ... I'm most likely a Republican with a marketing degree and ties to the oil industry. That would explain my views. Dismiss me.

Shame on them

Your right shame on them for demanding that we work towards clean air and clean water!
Shame on them for wanting to create thousands of new jobs in a sustainable industry!
Shame on them for wanting us to shed our dependence of foreign oil!
Everyone has the right to free speech.
No one left or right has the right to lie.
Bottom line, a clean environment is good for everybody. I for sure would like to not have to spend 10 percent of my yearly income on oil for my car and my house.
Just my 2 cents
Andrew Brinkworth
Charity Golf
Miami Auto Insurance

yea

How dare they give factual information on global temperatures since 2001 that show a cooling trend that flies in the face of every model prediction relied upon by the IPCC that show continued warming over this period, not one of which predicted this cooling.

Thats a great one. Enjoyed reading it thanks.

Dog Obedience

About the climate cover-up

About the climate cover-up

Democracy is utterly dependant upon an electorate that is accurately informed. In promoting climate change denial (and often denying their responsibility for doing so) industry has done more than endanger the environment. It has undermined democracy.

There is a vast difference between putting forth a point of view, honestly held, and intentionally sowing the seeds of confusion. Free speech does not include the right to deceive. Deception is not a point of view. And the right to disagree does not include a right to intentionally subvert the public awareness.

Although all public relations professionals are bound by a duty to not knowingly mislead the public, some have executed comprehensive campaigns of misinformation on behalf of industry clients on issues ranging from tobacco and asbestos to seat belts.

Lately, these fringe players have turned their efforts to creating confusion about climate change. This PR campaign could not be accomplished without the compliance of media as well as the assent and participation of leaders in government and business.

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Like what you read here? Get our top five stories in your inbox every week. » here's a preview
Enter your email and subscribe now!

Desmogblog monthly
book give-away

Enter now to win this month’s book Anthony Barnosky's Heatstroke: Nature in an age of global warming

CHECK IT OUT

Join One of DeSmog's Facebook Groups Today!

Join One of DeSmog's Facebook Groups Today!
Did you know DeSmog has some very active Facebook Groups? Check them out:

Friends of DeSmogBlog

The Arctic Front

The Environment is My Voting Issue in Canada

Expedition Earth

Member of the Progressive Bloggers Network

MEMBER OF THE PROGRESSIVE BLOGGERS NETWORK

Progressive Bloggers