Heartland: Selling Out Science in School

Fri, 2012-02-24 07:27Richard Littlemore
Richard Littlemore's picture

Heartland: Selling Out Science in School


Visit The Climate Reality Project for more. And read this message from 17-year-old Corey Husic to Heartland Institute CEO, Joseph Bast.


Dear Mr. Bast,

I'm Corey Husic, and I'm a high school student in Pennsylvania. It's come to my attention that you are prepared to spend a significant amount of money on a “global warming curriculum” to teach kids that climate change isn't real.

That's right. According to your own budget documents, you want to hand teachers a curriculum that says global warming is “a major scientific controversy” and that carbon dioxide might not even be a pollutant.

Please be advised: Your entire premise is false. The reality is that our climate is changing now and human activities are a primary cause. I’m just a high school student, so please don’t take my word for it. Just ask any National Academy of Science in the world or just about any actual climate scientist.

Given who pays your bills, your plan doesn’t come as a surprise. According to your own documents, your organization is funded by coal and oil companies with a financial stake in denying climate science — not to mention tobacco companies that tried to convince us smoking doesn't cause cancer.

My generation is already experiencing a very different climate from our parents and grandparents. We will be the ones responsible for making sure coastal cities are able to withstand rising sea levels. We are the ones who will have to protect ourselves from weather extremes like stronger hurricanes, longer droughts and hotter heat waves. Instead of trying to undermine the science that shows humans are causing climate change, we should be learning how those changes are going to affect us and what we can do about it. In other words, teach us something useful.

We respectfully demand that you cease and desist your effort to bring climate change denial into our schools.

Corey Husic
Age 17
Climate Presenter

Comments

From the Washington examiner;

FBI called in over climate change mole

“The Chicago-based free market Heartlans Institute
has called in the FBI and threatened other legal action against a
global warming proponent who has admitted stealing emails from the
institute in a bid to embarrass and discredit the group’s questioning of
climate change.

Heartland officials [stated] that they have been in talks with the
FBI over the case against prominent global warming proponent Peter
Gleick, co-founder of the respected Pacific Institute. Heartland is
getting ready to reveal their probe of the affair, which they hope the
FBI will act on.”

Your posts betray the fact that you’re talking about something other than science, Hank.  Even the conservative Washington Examiner refers to Heartland as a “free market” institute.  That’s got nothing to do with climate science.  So, what’s a “free market” institute involving itself is science?

Similarly you talk about the BBC’s “pro-green views and for being a strong supporter of the AGW movement” when in fact that is nothing more than accepting the established science. 

Take a look at Chris Mooney’s post about bad powerpoint presentations.  You shuold be struck by the fact that the AGU’s meeting involves tens of thousands of scientists and AAAS about eight thousand.  Those are big numbers of people engaged in science.  Compare that to anything Heartland has thrown.

The point is, Heartland is a political organization, not scientific.  If they disagree with the research, they should go try and get some papers published in the established journals.

The BBC, known for its pro-green views and for being a strong supporter of the AGW movement, discussed the Peter Gleick fiasco today on their World News radio program. Link to audio here;

http://www.bishop-hill.net/storage/WorldServicefakegate.mp3

Some key words used in their surprisingly honest report;

‘Perpetrator’, ‘Integrity’, ‘Deception’, ‘Credibilty’, ‘Public Trust’.

Again, no mention of the words ‘Whistleblower’ or ‘Hero’ anywhere.

 

All I saw was this Hank:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-17048991

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-17126699

Some key quotes and words in the surprisingly honest report:

“Denier-gate” is the label being applied in the blogosphere, in case you’re interested.

it’s a lobby group, paid to oppose regulation on a number of fronts - including climate change.

It’s probably most notable (or notorious) for holding an annual “climate-sceptic” conference in Washington DC.

“This strikes at the very roots of truth and freedom in a democratic society, something I would have felt the American people would find abhorrent,”

Further funding will go to climate blogger and former meteorologist Anthony Watts for a web-based project aiming to demonstrate problems in the US network of temperature monitoring stations - an issue whose irrelevance to the big questions of climate change was emphatically demonstrated last year by the Berkeley Earth Project, which found station quality was not a factor in modern measurements of global warming.

Heartland is not unique. We still have no idea, two years after its formation, of who funds the Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF) in the UK, nor what the funders’ motives are.

Who’s raising a flag now for openness in the lobbies of climate change debate?

 

Climate scientist Dr. Judith Curry has a new article;

“Why target Heartland?”

http://judithcurry.com/2012/02/24/why-target-heartland/

A key quote - “Gleick pointed a big gun at a small target and ended up shooting himself.”

Glieck got a document which appeared to be inside information from Heartland.  So he tried to figure out if it was true.

Its a shame he was unable to clear Heartland’s image with the information he got. (That was one potential outcome for his actions.)

That’s astounding Lara! Juddith Curry being a denier, running a denier blog, not writing something supportive about Gleick or how the denial industry is largely just paid to misinform, not practice science?

Phwoooarh, this is a revelation!

 

Good work guys and gals… you’re worth your money. Or it that free cigarettes?

http://thehill.com/blogs/e2-wire/e2-wire/212461-markey-wants-heartland-climate-documents

“…were obtained and released…”, “…releasing the documents to the news media…”

“The documents have caused a firestorm in Washington, with activists and others bashing the Heartland Institute for its plan to influence students.”

You see, easy game to play. Boring.

 

The earth is flat….

The sun revolves around the earth….

Bacteria don’t cause ulcers….

Acid rain is destroying forests and lake fora…..

Of course it’s true I learnt it in school…..

All because it’s the consensus, it doesn’t make it right.

 

All because it’s the consensus, it doesn’t make it right.”

No, but until someone comes up with evidence that changes the current paradigm, the consensus will remain. To date, that hasn’t happened and errr, denier blogs don’t count.

 

I wonder if Ian Plimer was told by his mate Bob Carter ( paid to deny AGW by Heartland) about Heartlands intentions to carpet bomb schools with fossil fuel propaganda?

http://www.desmogblog.com/climate-science-denier-ian-plimer-recruits-former-australian-pm-launch-book-targeting-children

Seems a bit too coincidental the timing of both publications.

Carter has admitted he is funded by Heartland to deny as well as being paid by various other right wing think tanks.

http://www.readfearn.com/2012/02/bob-carter-responds-to-heartland-leak/

“Heartland is one of a number of think-tanks and institutions that I work with. Sometimes I’m paid an honorarium, sometimes expenses and sometimes I do it pro-bono.”

Professor Carter is certainly correct here. He is indeed an advisor on a number of “think-tanks” and groups. In addition to Heartland, Professor Carter is an advisor to the Institute for Public Affairs (Aus), The Galileo Movement (Aus), the Science and Public Policy Institute (US), the International Climate Science Coalition (US/Canada), the Australian Climate Science Coalition, the Global Warming Policy Foundation (UK) and Repeal the Act (UK). He was a founding advisor to the New Zealand Climate Science Coalition.

Professor Carter added: “The details of any of these payments are private to me. I can’t imagine that Heartland has released this document – so the question is, how this document was released.”

Professor Carter said: “Scientists are paid not to have agendas or opinions, but to summarise the scientific evidence.”

Now I have to say I found this last statement pretty rich, coming from someone who is continually writing opinion pieces for newspapers and websites.

“Professional scientists cannot have their opinion bought,” he said, adding it was not important who funded research, but whether or not it was correct.

This is an odd assertion for Professor Carter to make, given that he has regularly over the years attempted to suggest that mainstream climate scientists are motivated by research dollars.

Oddly, on Professor Carter’s webpage he chooses to state that he receives no research funding from “special interest organisations such as environmental groups, energy companies or government departments”.

Contradictions galore.



 

Carter admits:

Professional scientists cannot have their opinion bought”

Says it right there, he is not a professional scientist just a shill for greedy and immoral fossil fuel corporations.

I think these Heartland materials sound like the ALEC plans discussed earlier.

http://www.desmogblog.com/alec-model-bill-behind-push-require-climate-denial-instruction-schools

Heartland has been involved with ALEC for years.  Do a Full Search for ALEC in Fake science…

See also Fakeducation For Years From Heartland, including link to Gareth Renowden's furthe look at the old “lesson plans.”

One might wonder how the money got to Sovereingty International.

 
[x]

AN Australian Federal MP is planning to join some of the world’s noisiest deniers of the science of climate change at a conference in Las Vegas in a few weeks time.

George Christensen, the National Party member for Dawson in the coal-friendly state of Queensland, will be hanging around the Mandelay Bay Resort with a rag-tag bunch of mostly long-retired academics and well paid think-tank associates for the Heartland Institute ...

read more