Oil On The Tracks: Canadian Pacific Rail Spills 30,000 Gallons of Crude in Minnesota

Thu, 2013-03-28 10:31Ben Jervey
Ben Jervey's picture

Oil On The Tracks: Canadian Pacific Rail Spills 30,000 Gallons of Crude in Minnesota

Who ever saw this coming? Yesterday, a Canadian Pacific train carrying crude oil jumped the tracks in Parkers Prarie, Minnesota and immediately spilled 20,000 to 30,000 gallons of crude onto the snowy, frozen fields.

Fourteen cars of the 94-car, mile-long train (stop and picture that for a moment) left the tracks during an emergency braking maneuver, the cause of which is yet unclear. The National Transportation Safety Board is conducting an immediate review.

According to Reuters, “the company did not comment as to what kind of crude the train was carrying,” and Canadian Pacific spokesman Ed Greenberg said he “did not know if the oil that spilled was tar sands oil.”

But we do know that the oil was coming from Western Canada and bound for Chicago. 

We've covered the growing trend of hauling crude oil by train, as pipelines have reached full capacity and opposition to new pipeline construction has stalled out projects like Keystone XL.

First, I looked at the current boom in so-called “oil trains” in the Dakotas to handle the glut in crude from the Bakken Shale prospects. And here's a post about Nexen's plans to ship tar sands crude west to Pacific Coast ports for export to China. I
n Feb. 2012 DeSmog's Steve Horn also documented magnate Warren Buffett's ownership of Burlington Northern Santa Fe (BNSF) via his holding corporation Berkshire Hathaway. BNSF is currently carrying tar sands-related products on the railways, including diluent used to make tar sands transport possible via pipeline.  

Luckily, because the ground was frozen and because the spill didn’t occur near any surface water, environmental impact appears minimal. But this should certainly still serve as a wake-up call. If the train had jumped the tracks near a river or stream, or during warmer months, cleanup would be much more difficult, and some pollution of groundwater and aquatic ecosystems would be inevitable.

Predictably, supporters of the Keystone XL pipeline are using this accident to advocate for construction of the controversial line.

“It should be clear that we need to move more oil by pipeline rather than by rail or truck,” said Don Canton, spokesman for North Dakota Senator John Hoeven, who has been one of the chief political proponents of the line. “This is why we need the Keystone XL. Pipelines are both safe and efficient.”

Because, no, pipelines never spill.

Photo: Minnesota Pollution Control Agency/Doug Bellefeuille

Comments

Train cars are smaller and only leak a small amount if they rupture. Its only logical.

Enbridge's spill in Michigan dumped 10 times as much from a small rupture.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enbridge_oil_spill

Clean up from that one was $765 million and climbing!

I wonder if they factor the spill savings in using trains to ship oil?

This is why we need pipelines! Nobody wants to admit the obvious, that it's more risky to move oil and gas by train!

The opposition to the pipelines is just sand being thrown in your face.  Its all about Climate Change and preventing environmental damage, nothing more.

Please enjoy this article about how we Albertans gas our citizens in the tar sands.  Buy this oil if you want to gas more farmers.

http://thetyee.ca/News/2013/03/02/Tar-Sand-Pollution-Refugees/?utm_sourc...

Did you catch the part about there being zero regulations in the tar sands for venting neuro toxins in the air?  Interesting, eh?

Come on guys, these train cars were carrying 'ethical oil”. Which means any spill would be practically harmless. CP Rail is also a good Canadian “ethical” company. I'm sure they were out with their pails and mops right away.

Let's not jump to any conclusions before Ezra Levant has had a chance to weigh in.

Its new from Harper Brothers!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qev7cwddseM

Psst… I hear Ethical Oil practically green washes itself!

[x]
Oil by rail

In 2009, Matt Taibbi wrote a piece in Rolling Stone in which he described the investment bank Goldman Sachs as “a great vampire squid wrapped around the face of humanity, relentlessly jamming its blood funnel into anything that smells like money.” 

Apparently tar sands oil smells like money. And thus the vampire squid has found another target. As Reuters reported on August 29:

... read more