Wall Street Journal's Bret Stephens' Sick Souled Neurosis [2]
"Global warming is a sick-souled religion." [7]
Really?
Wall Street Journal columnist Bret Stephens thinks so in his article, Global Warming as Mass Neurosis [7].
Unfortunately for Stephens' and the rest of the planet, his evidence for such an inflammatory claim doesn't stand up to scrutiny.
As evidence of this 'sick religion' Stephens points to US temperature records:
"NASA now begrudgingly confirms that the hottest year on record in the continental 48 was not 1998, as previously believed, but 1934, and that six of the 10 hottest years since 1880 antedate 1954."
Not to beat a point to death, but when the NASA temperature mistake was discovered, it was considered an insignificant adjustment by Bret Stephens himself [9] [not Steve Milloy as I mistakenly attributed the following quote] who stated at the time that "I [he] am [is] prepared to acknowledge that Mr. McIntyre's discovery amounts to what a New York Times reporter calls a 'statistically meaningless' rearrangement of data."
Okay, now I am beating the point to death, but when you compare NASA temperature records to the temperature records kept by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), the official US Government US temperature tracking agency, [10] the hottest year in the United States remains to be 1998. [11] NOAA recently reported that the 2006 average annual temperature for the contiguous U.S. was the 2nd warmest on record. [12]
On Arctic Sea Ice Stephens writes:
"The Arctic ice cap may be thinning, but the extent of Antarctic sea ice has been expanding for years."
Yes the Arctic ice cap is thinning [13] and the old, thick ice that can withstand significant thawing under summer temperatures is being replaced by thin, seasonal ice that melts away much quicker in the spring. And this is something that has scientists very concerned, because as the old ice continues to be replaced by seasonal thin ice, the extent of the summer polar ice cap melting is increasing year-after-year. [14] On the decreasing Arctic sea ice, National Snow and Ice Data Center (NSIDC) released a statement yesterday that:
"Arctic sea ice extent [15] for June 2008 is close to that for 2007, which went on to reach the lowest minimum since at least 1979. More notably, however, satellite data indicate that melt began significantly earlier than last year over most of the Arctic Ocean. The large area of the Arctic Ocean covered by first-year ice (described in our June analysis [16]) coupled with the early onset of melting may mean more rapid and more severe summer ice retreat than last year."
Losing Arctic sea ice earlier and earlier every year is a concern to scientists because the earth's sea ice acts as a massive white reflector, bouncing the sun's heat back out into space - the less sea ice, the less of the Sun's heat is reflected back into space, the more heat that is absorbed by the earth, the hotter it gets, the faster the melting. You can read the more scientific explanation of this under the heading Why earlier melt matters, [13] on the NSIDC website.
On Ocean Temperature Stephens writes:
Stephens uses all of this evidence above to conclude that "Global warming is sick-souled religion." [7] To make such an inflammatory statement, one that implicates Rupert Murdoch, [18] the owner of the newspaper he works for, you would think Stephens would have taken the time to at least ensure he had his facts straightened away.
And considering how flimsy Stephens apparent facts on the 'hysteria of global warming' appear to be, it is fair to say that the only one acting on faith and false-belief is Stephens himself.
[26]
[5]
[4]
[27]