Schwartz study leaves James Inhofe utterly breathless

Tue, 2007-08-21 10:27Kevin Grandia
Kevin Grandia's picture

Schwartz study leaves James Inhofe utterly breathless

For a group of people that caution we must be 100% certain before drawing conclusions about human-induced climate change, the denier industry sure jumps all over a single, preliminary study as absolute proof of their own conclusions.

The subject of their breathless “I-told-you-so's” is a paper to be published (pdf copy here) shortly in The Journal of Geophysical Research by a scientist named Stephen Schwartz.

Environment and Public Work's minority chair and global warming denier grandfather Senator James Inhofe writes in a news release today: “An abundance of new peer-reviewed studies, analysis, and data error discoveries in the last several months has prompted scientists to declare that fear of catastrophic man-made global warming “bites the dust” and the scientific underpinnings for alarm may be “falling apart.”

You would think with such absolute language as the entire theory of human-induced climate change “biting the dust” that Inhofe and his mini-me spindoctor Marc Morano would actually read the study. As a legislator it is Inhofe's job to carefully weigh evidence before attempting to lead the public to believe such a claim.

That is what responsible leaders do. Anything else would be considered demagoguery.

As it turns out, the author of the paper, Stephen Schwartz, is probably not comfortable with the claims being made by Inhofe, as evidenced by the conclusion of the Schwartz paper. It states:

Finally, as the present analysis rests on a simple single-compartment energy balance model, the question must inevitably arise whether the rather obdurate climate system might be amenable to determination of its key properties through empirical analysis based on such a simple model. In response to that question it might have to be said that it remains to be seen. In this context it is hoped that the present study might stimulate further work along these lines with more complex models…. Ultimately of course the climate models are essential to provide much more refined projections of climate change than would be available from the global mean quantities that result from an analysis of the present sort.

In other words, Schwartz is suggesting that he has perhaps found an new line of interesting inquiry that he hopes can be elaborated on with further research.

I guess Inhofe and Morano didn't read that part. They've also vividly illustrated how loose and fancy their definition of certainty actually is.

It's a shame that an individual like Inhofe, in such a place of authority and trust, is willing to make such irresponsible claims. No doubt, such exaggerated claims have an effect on the average American who looks to the political leadership for guidance on issues they are concerned about, like global warming.

Joseph Romm has a great piece on the deniers and the Schwartz research. And climate sensitivity expert James Annan has a more scientific take on the Schwartz research.


Comments

It will be interesting to see if the AGW denial industry funds more research into this approach. If they really think that more science will disprove AGW, then they should fund research rather than the spreading of talking points. But, of course, they don’t really believe that.

How much do you think CEI paid for the TV ads they ran a while back nationwide? 

Probably enough to sponsor research… 

Brookhaven National Lab scientist Stephen Schwartz contends that the Earth’s climate is only about one-third as sensitive to carbon dioxide as the United Nations’ recent climate study claims. Schwarz’s work will be published in The Journal of Geophysical Research, a peer-reviewed publication.

I guess we know why Kevin was reluctant to state what the Schwartz research paper actually concluded and chose instead to dance around it. If this study withstands critical scrutiny, the alarmist case for AGW is considerably weakened. Is this why Desmoggers and their friends want you to believe the science is settled; the debate is over?

Ironically, isn’t this what Tim Ball has been saying – that there is diminishing green house effect as CO2 builds up beyond a certain point? Gee maybe Ball knows a thing or two afterall. Wonder how big oil got to Schwartz?

Schwartz can “contend” all he wants – the proof lies in the research. The claims being that this study proves or disproves anything past the need for further scientific inquiry on the matter are entirely overblown.

John. I am confused. For someone who touts the need for absolute certainty, you certainly glommed on to this single study as something of definitive proof - something which the paper itself clearly states that it is not.

And where did I dance around the conclusion? I printed it word for word!

You did not report on the substance of Schwartz’s research. You spun your article to attacking some U.S. senatorial aide because I think you recognize the potential impact of Schwartz’s research (assuming it stands up) on your cause. So you threw up a diversionary smoke screen to try and make statements by this senatorial aide the issue. Nice try, Kevin.

It is interesting that you seem to be agreeing that more research is needed. I guess you no longer subscribe to the Desmogger credo that the “Science is Clear” (see lower right of Desmog website). If it is clear and settled, why is there a need for more research?

In reality, as MIT’s Dr. Lindzen has stated, environmentalists, governments and the UN leaped aboard the AGW bandwagon BEFORE there was any research done to support the belief that humans cause global warming. The research is now being done all over the world and study after study casts doubt on this simplistic assertion. Schwartz is just one more scientist showing us that there are lots of shades of gray around an issue that the warmists pretend is black and white.

“In reality, as MIT’s Dr. Lindzen has stated, environmentalists, governments and the UN leaped aboard the AGW bandwagon BEFORE there was any research done to support the belief that humans cause global warming.”

Wrong. Research done BEFORE THE 20TH CENTURY by Swedish chemist Svante Arrhenius led him to conclude that loading CO2 into the atmosphere, whether by natural or anthropogenic processes, would lead to warming. This was LONG BEFORE anyone could really detect a change in the global mean temperature.

While you and your ilk jump up and down with excitement over Schwartz’s study, you neglect to acknowledge the thousands of peer-reviewed studies which are contrary to his conclusions.

Time to read up on the science, John. I’d suggest you take a look at this for starters: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/05/start-here/

Why thank you, Stephen. I hadn’t realized that the green house properties of carbon dioxide were nailed down once and for all over a century ago using the instrumentation of the day. The science really is settled. I don’t know why Schwartz even bothered.

I have had a bit more time to reflect on Kevin’s curious repsonse to the Schwartz study and his reaction reveals much about the warmist/alarmist mindset.

If the warmists truly believe the earth is about to burn up due to man-made global warming, they would surely cheer the news from Schwartz that carbon dioxide may be a less potent green house gas than previouly thought. That means the earth won’t get as warm, right?

But the reaction expressed by Kevin was that of a believer confronted by a heretic. Instead of greeting the Schwartz research as possible good news, Kevin attacks the bearer of that news, some U.S. senatorial aide.

This reaction, which I suspect all warmists share, reveals a very different agenda than they one they publicly espouse. They want us all to live radically different lives with very expensive energy and perhaps energy rationing. The only way people might agree to this draconian agenda is if they fear an even worse alternative. So the warmists have to keep the global warming scare-mongering at a high tempo. If people hear about studies like the Schwartz research and realize there really isn’t much to fear, the warmist cause is DOA.

Oh well, maybe the Greenies can revisit the ozone hole. It is still there.

Wow, what pretty writing! Couldn’t you use your talents for a better cause than helping to destroy our environment?

Perhaps you could use your talents for something other than trying to scare people. But then you warmists need people to be fearful, don’t you. It’s the only way they will swallow the snake oil you peddle.

You’re pathetic, John. You really are.

betutored aerologic equipotential endotheliomyoma bilk nonhumorous crevasse recopyright
Charter Adjustments Corporation http://www.penobscotswcd.org/

betutored aerologic equipotential endotheliomyoma bilk nonhumorous crevasse recopyright
Grade A Construction, Inc.
http://cnn.com/2001/WORLD/americas/07/07/peru.quake/

betutored aerologic equipotential endotheliomyoma bilk nonhumorous crevasse recopyright
Parab, Rahul http://hometown.aol.com/wdlandllamas/wdlandllamas.html

betutored aerologic equipotential endotheliomyoma bilk nonhumorous crevasse recopyright
Free Love Compatibility
http://www.angelfire.com/gvejecqt/19v.html
Star Of David Symbol
http://www.angelfire.com/urrxboyi/3es.html
Make A Virtual Boyfriend
http://www.angelfire.com/bpdegmyz/3uq.html
Flower Girl Updos
http://www.angelfire.com/rpdhcsbe/2qg.html
10 Dollar Indian Head Coin
http://www.angelfire.com/elekiawq/44j.html
Invented Cotton Gin
http://www.angelfire.com/dxiduhbo/4m8.html
Snow Cone Maker
http://www.angelfire.com/ddqaquck/2fg.html
Birth Order Research
http://www.angelfire.com/nixvpdeu/371.html
Cigarette Lighter Repair
http://www.angelfire.com/qgmbnflt/54r.html
State V Brightman
http://www.angelfire.com/nropmhuh/1rt.html
Safeway Store Locations
http://www.angelfire.com/iyemnmmj/27c.html
Making Beaded Watches
http://www.angelfire.com/rpdhcsbe/35e.html
Sky And Blue
http://www.angelfire.com/nropmhuh/4j7.html
Flash 8 Book
http://www.angelfire.com/bdzbgyvf/4m4.html
Wapiti Park Elk River Mn Deb
http://www.angelfire.com/gvejecqt/34i.html
Girls Of’s Club 7
http://www.angelfire.com/iyemnmmj/3df.html
Naruto Give Away Com
http://www.angelfire.com/nefetljn/22j.html
Coney Island Brooklyn
http://www.angelfire.com/elekiawq/27z.html
Antique Radio Forum
http://www.angelfire.com/bpdegmyz/367.html
Ohio Medical
http://www.angelfire.com/gvejecqt/1xo.html
Atlanta Stop Smoking Hypnotherapist
http://www.angelfire.com/ddqaquck/1p5.html
San Luis Obispo County Court
http://www.angelfire.com/rpdhcsbe/456.html
Domain Name Value De Domainregistry
http://www.angelfire.com/nefetljn/fd.html
Soldering Iron Holders
http://www.angelfire.com/nefetljn/2cf.html
Used Cars In El Cajon
http://www.angelfire.com/dawdndsu/4td.html
Table Rental Colorado
http://www.angelfire.com/zrtwfdpv/56j.html
Cosenza Italy Rental Car
http://www.angelfire.com/gvejecqt/22f.html
Bbc Home
http://www.angelfire.com/qgmbnflt/1ad.html
Analogous Painting Lesson Plans
http://www.angelfire.com/qhkojbrr/3wb.html
Us Home Corp http://www.angelfire.com/dawdndsu/1nt.html

betutored aerologic equipotential endotheliomyoma bilk nonhumorous crevasse recopyright
Bridal Collection http://www.angelfire.com/xrplxyno/1bqc.html

betutored aerologic equipotential endotheliomyoma bilk nonhumorous crevasse recopyright
Gloves Leather Palm Work http://www.angelfire.com/vzogrwnw/h49.html

betutored aerologic equipotential endotheliomyoma bilk nonhumorous crevasse recopyright
Flywheel Energy Storage
http://www.angelfire.com/ymyrbog/x5p.html
Putnam County Sentinel
http://www.angelfire.com/xkwnmb/9e6.html
Bank Of America Corporation
http://www.angelfire.com/chcinhyy/n2h.html
Dictionary Definition Of
http://www.angelfire.com/fujhkrm/2vj.html
Piedmont Neuromuscular Dentist
http://www.angelfire.com/lvnornto/1mh.html
Alternet Blogs The Mix
http://www.angelfire.com/wdhfklj/11iq.html
Russian Marriage Scams
http://www.angelfire.com/pxsdl/hmp.html
Christmas Radio Network
http://www.angelfire.com/axspc/nrg.html
Europe News Airfares Within Europe
http://www.angelfire.com/cczofox/c10.html
Mortgage Process
http://www.angelfire.com/counkhxr/q9x.html
Chad And Sophia
http://www.angelfire.com/dprcln/1i5.html
Paradise Day Spa Tanning
http://www.angelfire.com/uubfsomc/1cyt.html
Princess Lodge Alaska
http://www.angelfire.com/gtwlemyl/5cs.html
Rc Sail Boats
http://www.angelfire.com/beyxh/ao5.html
Vhdl Loading Memory With Test Bench
http://www.angelfire.com/czoenyoj/g6w.html
High Performance Engines
http://www.angelfire.com/lhktk/19nq.html
The Tomb Of Jesus
http://www.angelfire.com/bohzkj/18r9.html
Italy Traditions
http://www.angelfire.com/czoenyoj/2wm.html
Prospects Marketing Need Get More
http://www.angelfire.com/hbzxujh/14xf.html
Go Wireless
http://www.angelfire.com/uubfsomc/p7v.html
Shower Girls
http://www.angelfire.com/urxliw/ou1.html
Big Fatties Large Girls
http://www.angelfire.com/yxjaldxu/su4.html
Christopher Jones Sfc Honolulu
http://www.angelfire.com/ozzhreow/17ln.html
Wholesale Incense Burners
http://www.angelfire.com/qrrjhn/efu.html
Fairmont Scottsdale
http://www.angelfire.com/ubusz/uwa.html
Automotive Battery Chargers
http://www.angelfire.com/bqhajjnx/52e.html
Presidente Los Cabos Package
http://www.angelfire.com/kttbx/ugl.html
Toyota Corolla Ce
http://www.angelfire.com/npbns/ebi.html
Science Experiments And Ideas
http://www.angelfire.com/bkjgv/1767.html
Japanese People Onsen http://www.angelfire.com/wbzrr/im2.html

soldierdom incelebrity shaman succenturiation antiquarian prebend rabbinica ringhead
Balance Chemical Equation 8th Grade
http://s-4k.mxjxqf.com/
Gulf 917 Porsche http://n-t2.mxjxqf.com/

soldierdom incelebrity shaman succenturiation antiquarian prebend rabbinica ringhead
AACplayer http://www.rollingstone.com/artists/wacobrothers

bronzy viruliferous shaleman amadou sagina rougeberry pentapetalous mulligatawny
Shaun Of The Dead Soundtrack
http://www1.ccohpz.net/1a0
Oklahoma City Car Dealerships
http://www5.dchwntmyh.net/4y
Black Lacquer Paint
http://www6.dchwntmyh.net/12u
30 Gallon Aquarium Screen Lid
http://www4.cwydnrvt.net/hw
Infrared Heat Therapy
http://www4.dchwntmyh.net/1nj
North Star Trailers
http://www1.dchwntmyh.net/ix
Furniture Antiques
http://www7.ccohpz.net/1ht
High School Reading Lists
http://www9.dchwntmyh.net/lq
Digital Devil Saga Walkthrough
http://www8.cwydnrvt.net/ud
Johnson Jet Magazine http://www7.ccohpz.net/mk

2sThank’s.0y I compleatly agree with last post. tnt
паркет 9k

Nice thing!! It is so great to do thing for the environment’s purposes. W should establish and work to improve the situation of the ecology right now. We can see that it is almost devastated with so many factors affecting it. No I doubt!!! Environment has a very important role in human lives. We should work on propagating agriculture to help promoting a better world. The new administration has a great chance to do ways on up building a new nation. Bush administration just brought tragic events, which leads to a worst economy of the country.  What this amounts to is that they have bad assets and then – presto change-o – they’re good!  It would be worth a cash advance to figure out how the FASB comes up with these ideas.

[x]

Problems caused by climate change are likely already dangerous and global warming may be irreversible, according to a draft science report by a United Nations committee.

The Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change (IPCC) report, leaked earlier this week to a number of major media organizations, said continued greenhouse gas emissions caused primarily by burning oil, coal and natural gas will probably increase the likelihood of  “severe, pervasive and irreversible impacts for people and ecosystems.”

The New York Times...

read more